EXW, FOB, CIF: who owns the risk at each point
Most disputes about shipping terms are not about price. They are about the moment when a damaged crate stops being the seller's problem. That moment is defined by the Incoterm, and it is different for each one.
The three terms side by side
| EXW | FOB | CIF | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seller handles export clearance | No | Yes | Yes |
| Seller pays inland freight to port | No | Yes | Yes |
| Seller pays ocean freight | No | No | Yes |
| Seller arranges insurance | No | No | Yes (minimum cover) |
| Risk passes to buyer | At the factory | When cargo is on board | When cargo is on board |
| Buyer handles import clearance | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Typical use | Repeat buyers with own forwarder | Container shipments | Buyers who want one invoice |
The line worth reading twice is the risk transfer for CIF. Paying freight and insurance does not move the risk point. If the container is lost at sea under CIF, the buyer claims on the insurance policy - the seller's obligation was to arrange it, not to carry the loss.
Why we quote EXW Shenzhen
EXW is the term we use for every enquiry. Not because it is cheaper for us - it usually is not, since we still prepare export documents when asked - but because it keeps the responsibility boundary unambiguous. The buyer's forwarder collects at the factory, and from that moment the routing, the consolidation, the customs broker and the insurance are all on one side of the line.
Buyers who already have a forwarder in Shenzhen prefer this: they consolidate several suppliers into one container and control the schedule. Buyers who do not have one often ask us to recommend a forwarder, which we do. The recommendation is free; the freight contract stays in the buyer's name, and so does the liability.
The cost lines each term moves
| Cost line | Under EXW | Under FOB | Under CIF |
|---|---|---|---|
| Export declaration | Buyer (or agent) | Seller | Seller |
| Trucking factory to port | Buyer | Seller | Seller |
| Terminal handling origin | Buyer | Seller | Seller |
| Ocean freight | Buyer | Buyer | Seller |
| Marine insurance | Buyer | Buyer | Seller |
| Destination charges | Buyer | Buyer | Buyer |
A quote that says "freight included" without naming the term is not a quote. Ask which Incoterm, and at which named place. "CIF Hamburg" and "CIF" are different statements, and only one of them is enforceable.
Three practical traps
Trap 1: EXW and export paperwork
Under strict EXW the buyer is responsible for export clearance in the country of origin, which is awkward if the buyer has no entity there. Most Chinese suppliers handle the export declaration anyway as a service. Get that in writing, otherwise your forwarder will ask for a document nobody agreed to produce.
Trap 2: insurance cover under CIF
CIF requires minimum cover - typically Institute Cargo Clauses (C), which excludes many partial losses. If your parts are high value or fragile, specify ICC (A) in the contract. The difference in premium is small; the difference in what gets paid is not.
Trap 3: who inspects before shipment
Under EXW the seller's obligation ends at the factory gate, so any damage after that is a transport claim. That makes the pre-shipment inspection the buyer's last clear look at the goods. If you cannot inspect in person, ask for photographs of the packed cartons with the packing list visible, taken before collection.
What to write in the purchase order
- The exact term and named place: EXW Shenzhen (Shajing, Bao'an), not just EXW.
- Who files the export declaration, if it is not the default for the term.
- The packing standard, if the parts are sensitive to humidity or impact.
- The inspection point and who attends it.
One sentence in the PO prevents most of the arguments that show up three weeks later as a photo of a crushed carton and two people pointing at each other.
A worked example with real numbers
One pallet, 180 kg, Shenzhen to Rotterdam, 1.2 m³. Rough numbers, because freight moves, but the structure holds:
| Line | Amount (USD) | Who pays under EXW | Who pays under FOB | Who pays under CIF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Export declaration + documents | 40-80 | Buyer | Seller | Seller |
| Trucking Shajing to Yantian | 90-140 | Buyer | Seller | Seller |
| Origin terminal handling | 60-110 | Buyer | Seller | Seller |
| Ocean freight (LCL, 1.2 m³) | 180-320 | Buyer | Buyer | Seller |
| Marine insurance (ICC A) | 15-30 | Buyer | Buyer | Seller |
| Destination THC + delivery | 150-250 | Buyer | Buyer | Buyer |
Notice that the CIF column just collects more lines into one invoice. The total is the same plus the seller's handling margin. What changes is who has to talk to the forwarder, and who holds the claim if the pallet arrives wet.
The mistake that costs the most
The expensive mistake is not choosing the wrong term. It is leaving the term blank on the purchase order and discovering the disagreement when the forwarder asks who is paying the origin charges. At that point the cargo is already at the terminal and every day of delay costs storage.
Write the term, the named place, and the packing standard in the PO. Three lines. It is the cheapest insurance in the whole transaction.
What about DDP and DAP
DAP puts delivery at the buyer's door with the seller bearing transport risk to that point, but the buyer still clears import. DDP adds import clearance and duty, which requires the seller to be registered as importer of record in the destination country - a tax presence, not just a shipping arrangement.
That is why we quote EXW. DDP is a logistics product, not a machining term, and a forwarder can wrap it around our EXW price if that is what the buyer needs.
Questions buyers ask
Is EXW worse for the buyer than FOB?
Not worse, just more work. EXW gives the buyer full control of routing and consolidation, often at a lower total cost if they ship regularly. It is worse only if the buyer has no forwarder and no experience with export formalities.
Can you ship DDP?
We quote EXW Shenzhen only. DDP requires the seller to act as importer of record in the destination country, which brings tax registration and liability we do not take on. A forwarder can arrange DDP service on the buyer's behalf.
Who pays if the goods are damaged in transit under CIF?
The insurer, under the policy the seller arranged. Risk passed to the buyer when the cargo went on board, so the claim is the buyer's to file - which is why the cover level matters and should be specified, not left at the CIF minimum.
Does the Incoterm change the price much?
It changes which lines appear on the invoice, not the underlying cost. Freight and insurance are the same numbers whether the seller or the buyer pays them; the term only decides who is billed.
Does EXW mean the buyer must pick up at the machine shop?
It means risk and cost transfer at the seller's premises. In practice the buyer's forwarder sends a truck to the factory and the seller loads it. Loading assistance is a separate agreement, not part of EXW.
Can I use my own forwarder under CIF?
Under CIF the seller chooses and pays the carrier, so your forwarder has no role. If you want to control routing, ask for FOB or EXW instead.
Shipping terms, MOQ and lead times are stated in full on the main site.
send a drawing for review