How many shops should you quote before choosing one?
Why three
With two quotes you know there is a spread, not which side is unusual. With three you can see whether the middle value is a real market level or whether two shops happen to be aligned. With four, the fourth quote almost never changes the decision - by then you already know the range.
There is a second, less obvious reason. Shops triage enquiries. A buyer who sends the same drawing to eight suppliers often gets eight quick estimates, because nobody expects to win it. A buyer who sends it to three gets at least one shop that reads the drawing and comes back with questions - and that shop is usually the one worth using.
What the spread means
| Spread across three quotes | Likely explanation | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Within 10% | Same route, same assumptions | Choose on lead time and communication |
| 20-40% | Different route or different finishing scope | Ask each for the process route before deciding |
| 50-100% | One quote misunderstood the drawing, or one is a rush quote | Ask for the route; also ask what changes if the tolerance is relaxed |
| Over 100% | Different process entirely (e.g. EDM vs milling) or a shop that does not want the job | Treat the high quote as a signal, not a price |
A high quote is information. It often means the shop would have to buy a tool, build a fixture or subcontract a step - which tells you something about your part that the cheap quotes did not mention.
Making quotes comparable
Three quotes on three different assumption sets are not a comparison. Before you send the RFQ, put these in it:
- Drawing revision and material grade, stated explicitly (not "aluminium").
- Lot size, and the lot size you expect to repeat at.
- Tolerance expectation: full drawing, or note which dimensions can run to the general tolerance.
- Finishing: included or quoted separately.
- Inspection: what report you expect.
- Delivery term and destination.
Then ask each shop to quote in the same structure. A quote that arrives as a single number with "ex works" at the bottom cannot be compared to one that breaks out material, machining, finishing and inspection.
When to quote more than three
- New process for you - first time buying a process (EDM, honing, heat treat) you do not yet know the market level.
- Large order - at 10,000+ pieces the differences are structural and worth a wider search.
- Suspect capability - if one quote is much lower, get a fourth to test whether the low one is the outlier.
- Lead time critical - quoting more shops is sometimes really about finding who has capacity this month.
The signals that matter more than price
After the quotes come back, the deciding factors are usually not the number:
| Signal | What good looks like | What should worry you |
|---|---|---|
| Response to the drawing | Questions about a specific feature | A price with no questions |
| Process description | Names the machine and the number of setups | "We can do it" |
| Tolerance comment | Flags the dimensions that will be difficult | Silence on a ±0.005 callout |
| Lead time | A number of days plus dependencies | "As soon as possible" |
| Finishing | Named subcontractor, named process | "Standard finish" |
A note on samples
If the part is critical, buy one sample before the batch - from the shop you are about to choose, not from all three. A sample costs a prototype price and answers the only question that matters: can this shop make this part. Three samples tells you three shops can or cannot; one sample tells you whether your choice works.
What actually happens when you send eight RFQs
In practice, eight enquiries produce a predictable pattern: three replies within 48 hours, two replies after a reminder, two "we will revert" that never revert, one that quotes a completely different part because an attachment did not open. The three fast replies are the ones you would have got from a three-shop RFQ - you have simply spent more time managing the other five.
There is a real cost to the buyer here: every quote has to be read, compared and answered with questions. Five comparable quotes take an afternoon to process; three take forty minutes and produce the same decision.
A comparison sheet that works
Put the quotes in a grid with the same rows for everyone. The rows that matter, in order:
| Row | Why it decides the choice |
|---|---|
| Unit price at your actual lot size | Quotes at a different quantity are not comparable |
| Setup / tooling charge, one-off | Often the real difference on small lots |
| Process route (machine, number of setups) | Explains the price, and predicts the lead time |
| Finishing included? | The most common hidden gap |
| Inspection included? | The second most common |
| Lead time, with dependencies | Excludes material ordering, usually |
| Delivery term | EXW vs FOB changes the total by 15-25% |
Fill it in before talking to anyone. Whichever shop cannot fill a row is the one to question - not necessarily to reject.
The one thing not to do
Do not tell a shop its competitor's exact price. It invites a cut that gets recovered somewhere invisible - a thinner coating, a skipped first article, a different material grade. Tell it the budget range if you need to; do not tell it the other number.
Questions buyers ask
Is it rude to send the same drawing to several shops?
No, it is normal practice, and shops assume it. What is discourteous is telling a shop it has the order while still collecting quotes.
Should I tell each shop what the others quoted?
You can tell a shop it is not the lowest, without naming the number. Naming a competitor's price invites a cut that is recovered elsewhere - in finishing, inspection or material grade.
What if the cheapest quote is also the fastest?
Then check scope: finishing, inspection, material certification and packing. A quote that is both cheapest and fastest is usually either genuinely efficient or quoting a narrower scope.
How long should I wait for quotes?
Three to five working days for a normal part. A shop that needs two weeks to estimate a simple turned part either does not want the job or does not have an estimator.
Send one drawing and we will send back a route, not just a number.
send a drawing for review