What a first-article report should contain
Why the first article is different from any other inspection
The first article is the only point where the whole process is proven at once: programme, tooling, fixture, gauges and material all meet for the first time. If it passes, the route is capable. If it fails, the route changes - and you want to know that before 500 parts are made, not after.
That is also why "we checked the first one, it was fine" is not a substitute for a report. Verbal confirmation cannot be audited and cannot be compared to the next run.
The six sections
1. Dimensioned results
- A balloon number or drawing reference for every line, so it maps back to the drawing.
- Four columns: nominal, upper/lower limit, measured, pass/fail. Three columns is not enough.
- Critical dimensions flagged, with a note on whether they are 100% or sampled.
- No blank rows. Blank rows are where the problem hides.
2. Material certificate
Check three things: the grade and temper match the drawing, the heat number matches the material actually drawn from stock, and the chemistry plus mechanical properties are on the certificate. A mill cert whose heat number cannot be traced to the lot is decoration.
3. Heat treat and finishing records
Heat treat: process, hardness measured values, furnace or batch reference. Finishing: type, coating thickness, colour reference, sealing method. Subcontracted operations must carry the subcontractor's own record - not a line saying "finished".
4. GD&T data with datums
Every geometric result must name its datum. "Concentricity 0.008" without stating the axis it is measured against cannot be evaluated. Also look for the measurement temperature; on precision work, a report without one is worth less.
5. Cosmetic and functional checks
Cosmetic: judged against a signed sample, a written description (scratch length, count, location) or a colour reference with a ΔE allowance. Functional: go/no-go, thread gauging, leak test, fit check. "Visual OK" is not a result.
6. Sign-off tied to the lot
Inspector name, date, report number, purchase order number, lot number. Without the lot tie, the report does not prove anything about the box in front of you.
Four reports that look complete but are not
| Type | How to spot it | Why it fails |
|---|---|---|
| Caliper-only report | Every value has two decimals | Cannot support ±0.005 or any GD&T |
| No balloon numbers | "Diameter 10.00" with no drawing reference | Cannot tell which feature was measured |
| Empty datum column | GD&T values without datum letters | Conclusion is undefined |
| "OK" instead of values | Measured column reads OK / PASS | No data, so no evidence |
Reading one in two minutes
- Start at the end: signature, date, PO number, lot number. Confirm it is your lot.
- Go to the critical dimensions and check the measured values, not the pass column.
- Check the datum letters on every GD&T line.
- Scan the remaining rows for blanks and for values sitting exactly on a limit (which usually means rounding).
- Check that the material heat number matches the packing list or the material tag.
What comes after the first article
The first article proves the start; process records prove the run. For a batch order, ask additionally for: in-process inspection frequency and results, tool change records on precision work, and a final inspection report. Those three make the difference between "it was right once" and "it was right throughout".
A sample line, and what makes it good
Here is one row from a report that would pass review:
| Balloon | Feature | Nominal | Limits | Measured | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 | Bore Ø | 8.000 | 7.985 / 8.015 | 7.998 | Pass |
| 18 | Position ⌖ Ø0.2 A B C | 0.200 | max 0.200 | 0.084 | Pass |
| 19 | Surface Ra | 0.8 | max 0.8 | 0.62 | Pass |
Three things make this usable: the balloon number ties to the drawing, the limits are explicit (not just the nominal), and the GD&T line names its datums. A report where the position row reads "OK" instead of 0.084 has no evidence behind it - you cannot tell whether the inspector measured or assumed.
How a first article is actually produced
- The process engineer balloons the drawing and issues a measurement plan.
- The part is machined; the operator checks the easy dimensions in-process.
- The part sits in the inspection room until it reaches 20 °C (2 hours minimum for steel).
- CMM programme runs; hard-to-reach features are measured on a height gauge or profile projector.
- Values are entered against the balloon numbers; any dimension outside limits goes to the engineer before the report is issued.
- The report is signed and, if the part passes, batch production is released.
The step buyers never see is number five. A shop that has this loop will often report a failure and re-cut the part before shipping anything - which is why a first article arriving with all values in the middle of the tolerance band is normal, not suspicious.
What to do with a report that fails
A failing first article is often more informative than a passing one, because it shows where the process margin is thin. Ask for the measured value against the limit, the cause, and the corrective action. If the answer is "we will adjust the offset and re-measure", that is a valid action provided the root cause is understood - an offset adjustment that masks a fixture problem will come back at piece 200.
Questions buyers ask
Is a first-article report the same as a full dimensional report?
Not quite. A full dimensional report covers dimensions only. A first-article report also covers material, processes, cosmetics and function, and usually includes the dimensional data as one section.
Do I need an FAI on a prototype?
Yes. A prototype is the extreme case of a first article. Without data, the only proof is whether it fits - and by then the geometry has already been accepted.
Can the report be produced after shipment?
The format can be re-issued; the data cannot be re-created. If the report is dated after the shipment date, ask when the measurement was actually taken.
What is the difference between FAI and PPAP?
FAI covers one part against the drawing. PPAP is a production-part approval package covering process capability, control plans and MSA as well. For general machining, FAI is normally enough; automotive customers may require PPAP.
Every lot ships with a CMM-measured first-article report; the inspection scope is on the quality page.
quality and inspection