CHX Precision Metal

Heat treat, plating and welding: who owns the dimension

Updated 2026-11-15 · CHX Precision Metal

Almost no machine shop runs its own heat treat, plating or welding. The risk is not the process - it is the boundary: the part changes size at a subcontractor, and when it arrives out of tolerance nobody owns it. Three things fix this: name the operations and the subcontractor on the order, fix the re-inspection items, and agree in advance what happens when a part is out.

The four operations that move dimensions

OperationWhy it is subcontractedEffect on sizeRe-inspect on return
Vacuum hardening / temperingFurnace cost, batch loadingDistortion; 0.05-0.3 mm on slender partsHardness, critical dimensions, straightness
Stress relief / ageingFurnace time, batchingShrinkage of tens of micronsCritical dimensions
AnodisingEnvironmental permitsHalf the coating grows outwardMating dimensions, coating thickness, colour
Plating (Ni / Zn / Au)SameCoating thickness adds directlyMating dimensions, thickness, adhesion
Laser or TIG weldingCertified weldersHeat-affected zone contracts and pullsWeld quality, flatness, leak test
Passivation / electropolishSameRemoves a few micronsSurface finish, dimensions on thin sections

Heat treat: how much stock to leave

Distortion depends on section and geometry, so there is no universal allowance. What experience gives is a band: solid blocks move very little; slender shafts (length/diameter above 5) can lose 0.05-0.3 mm of straightness in vacuum hardening; thin-wall cavities under 2 mm wall can lose 0.1 mm of flatness or more.

The consequence is a process rule: leave stock before heat treat, finish after it. On parts that must be delivered in the hardened condition, the drawing has to say which dimensions are guaranteed after heat treat and which are pre-machined - otherwise the first article is measured against requirements the process cannot meet.

One more thing worth putting on the order: gas quenching versus oil. Oil quenches faster and distorts more. For thin sections the difference can be the entire tolerance budget, and the price difference is small.

Plating: coating thickness is a machining decision

Electroless nickel typically runs 3-10 μm, zinc plating 5-15 μm, gold 0.05-0.3 μm. All of it grows outward. A Ø10 h7 shaft with 10 μm of nickel becomes Ø10.02 - which may no longer enter the bore it was designed for.

FeatureWhat plating doesThe three fixes
Close-tolerance shaftGrows by coating thickness x2 (diameter)Mask the area, plate then grind, or open the tolerance
ThreadPitch diameter closes; gauge will not enterPlate then tap, run thread oversize, or specify plating allowance
Blind holeDiameter shrinks; depth reduces slightlyMask, or drill oversize by 2x coating thickness
Sealing faceCoating can be porous or nodularSpecify thickness range and surface requirement together

The mistake is to treat plating as a cosmetic step and hand the part over after final inspection. If the drawing has a plating callout, the dimensional plan has to account for it - and that plan belongs to the machine shop, not the plater.

Welding: the heat-affected zone is the problem

A weld pulls. On a thin plate the distortion shows as bow; on a tube assembly it shows as misalignment at the far end. Two consequences: flatness requirements usually need either post-weld machining or a stress-relief cycle, and leak-tight assemblies need a leak test that is specified, not assumed.

If the part is a fluid or vacuum component, put the test on the drawing: medium, pressure, hold time, allowable leak rate. "Leak tested" without numbers is not a requirement, and it will not be performed consistently.

Fixing the boundary in three sentences

  1. Name the operations and the subcontractor on the purchase order - which steps go out, to whom, and what comes back verified.
  2. Fix the re-inspection items - hardness, critical dimensions, appearance. These are checked on return, before the part moves to the next step.
  3. Agree the disposition in advance - rework, scrap, or concession. This is where most disputes come from, and it costs one sentence to settle before the parts move.

Batch loading and the furnace ticket

Small lots get batched with other customers' work to fill a furnace. That is normal and it is why a 20-piece heat treat order can be affordable. What matters is the furnace ticket: batch reference, cycle, temperature, and the hardness results. Ask for it, and keep it with the lot record.

Without the ticket, you have a part that is hard but no evidence of how it got that way - which matters the day a customer asks for traceability and you have to reconstruct it from memory.

Auditing a subcontractor in twenty minutes

You will not usually visit the heat treater or the plater. What you can do is ask the machine shop four questions about them, and notice whether the answers are specific.

  1. Who is it, and how long have you used them? A named company and a multi-year relationship is a different answer from "a guy in Dongguan".
  2. What do they send back with the parts? A furnace ticket with batch reference and hardness values, or a plating thickness report. Not an invoice.
  3. What do you check on return, and who signs? If nothing is checked, the boundary is theoretical.
  4. What happened the last time a lot came back out of tolerance? A concrete story with a resolution is the strongest signal you will get in a phone call.

None of these require the buyer to manage the subcontractor directly - and doing so is usually a mistake, because it breaks the single point of responsibility that the machine shop is being paid for.

Questions buyers ask

Can the machine shop do heat treat in-house instead?

Some large shops do. For most, a furnace is idle most of the week and the environmental permitting is disproportionate. Subcontracting is normal; the discipline is in the boundary, not in owning the furnace.

Who pays when a heat-treated part comes back out of tolerance?

Contractually, the shop that sold you the part. Operationally, the shop argues with its subcontractor. This is why buyers should check the shop's re-inspection process rather than trying to deal with the heat treater directly.

Does anodising really change dimensions enough to matter?

At 20 μm coating, a bore shrinks about 0.02 mm and an outside diameter grows about 0.02 mm. On a ±0.05 tolerance that is 40% of the budget; on a press fit it is decisive.

Can welding be done before machining?

Yes, and often should be - weld, stress relieve, then machine. Machining before welding means the weld distortion lands on finished surfaces.

Can I nominate my own heat treater or plater?

Sometimes, and it complicates the contract: the shop still sells you the part, but has less control over a critical step. If you do nominate, agree in writing who inspects on return and who carries the scrap cost.

Heat treat, anodising and plating run through fixed subcontractors with return inspection recorded on the process card.

quality and inspection